The Quarterly Journal of Judicial Law Views

The Quarterly Journal of Judicial Law Views

Comparative Study of Civil Liability of Trustee in Iranian and French law

Authors
1 University of Justice and Administrative Services
2 University of Isfahan
Abstract
Abstract

In accordance Article 614 of the Civil Code, the Trustee is not liable except in the event of an infringement  or a failure. In French law, you are also absolved of liability and surety if you have no failure to pay the deposit. However, the main issue is the basis of responsibility and the condition of increasing or decreasing it. Is the basis of liability for the trustee of the law or of the contract and can it be reduced or rejected or increased during the deposit. The results of this research are that the responsibility for the Iranian law is unconstitutional (non-contractual) and in French law is contractual. Also, in Iranian law, the condition of increasing or decreasing this liability is not inconsistent with the permissibility of the deposit agreement. The condition of increase is not contrary to the nature of the deposit agreement and is only contrary to the consensus, and the condition of reduction or disclaimer is valid even in the event of an Infringement or a failure. In French law, the condition of increasing or decreasing this liability is valid in the loan agreement.
Keywords

Bell, John, Simon Whittaker, (1998), Principes of Fernch Law, Oxford University press.
J. Moitry, F.X. Testu, (1998), Responsabilie du fait des Produits Defectueux: Commentaire de la loi I 98-389 DU 19, at: www.testuavocats.
Mazeaud, Henri, Léon et Jean, (1995), Leçons de Droit Civil, Paris: montchrestien.
Prosser, William, (1964), The Law of Tort, USA: West publishing co.
Mazeaud, Henri, Jean et Léon, Michel de juglart, (1980), principaux contrats, Paris: montchrestien.
Ripert, Georges; et Roblot, (1976), Traité élémentaire de Droit Commerçial, Paris: Librairie Generals de droit et de jurisprudence.
Viney, Geneviève, (2009), Introduction à la responsabilité, 3e édition, L.G.D.J.
Starck, Boris, (1972), Droit civil. Obligations. 1é. éd. Paris: Librairies technniques.
Terré, François, Philippe Simler, Yves Lequette, (2002), Les Obligations, Dalloz.